Researchers and practitioners increasingly consider a human-centered perspective in the design of machine learning-based applications, especially in the context of Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI). However, clear methodological guidance in this context is still missing because each new situation seems to require a new setup, which also creates different methodological challenges. Existing case study collections in XAI inspired us; therefore, we propose a similar collection of case studies for human-centered XAI that can provide methodological guidance or inspiration for others. We want to showcase our idea in this workshop by describing three case studies from our research. These case studies are selected to highlight how apparently small differences require a different set of methods and considerations. With this workshop contribution, we would like to engage in a discussion on how such a collection of case studies can provide a methodological guidance and critical reflection.